I’m trying to see whether this is a contradiction, or if “just” means something different in each verse.
Community answers are sorted based on votes. The higher the vote, the further up an answer is.
Jeffrey Johnson
Supporter
To understand Matthew 5:45 alongside Ecclesiastes 7:20, you need to consider the difference between positional/comparative righteousness and absolute moral perfection. Understanding the Terms "The Just and Unjust" in Matthew 5:45: Jesus is speaking in the context of common grace—God's universal, daily provision of sunshine and rain that sustains life for everyone, regardless of moral character. In this functional and comparative sense, "just" (or righteous) and "unjust" (evil) describe general categories of human behaviour: people who try to live by God's standards versus those who actively rebel against them. Jesus uses these categories to show that God's love is impartial; He doesn't withhold basic life-giving provisions from His opponents. "No Just Man" in Ecclesiastes 7:20: The writer of Ecclesiastes speaks in an absolute, theological sense about human sin nature. Measured against God's standard of absolute holiness, every single human being falls short and sins. No one is righteous enough to merit salvation or claim completeness. You can hold Matthew 5:45 and Ecclesiastes 7:20 together without contradiction once you see they speak about different aspects of human life before God. Matthew 5:45 describes God's generosity toward all people, while Ecclesiastes 7:20 describes the moral condition of all people. No one is perfectly righteous, yet God still shows kindness to everyone. What Matthew 5:45 is actually teaching: Jesus says God "sends rain on the just and the unjust" to highlight God's character. In that context, rain is a blessing, not a punishment. It means: God gives life‑sustaining gifts to everyone. God does good even to those who do not honour Him. God's people should imitate that generosity. So "the just" in Matthew 5:45 refers to people who are living rightly in a practical, observable sense—those who act with integrity, kindness, or faithfulness. It does not claim they are morally perfect. What Ecclesiastes 7:20 is actually teaching: Ecclesiastes says: “There is no righteous man on earth who does good and never sins.” This statement speaks to universal human fallenness. Even the best person is still flawed. No one is righteous in the absolute, sinless sense. How they fit together: The key is that "righteous" or "just" can be used in more than one sense in Scripture: Relative righteousness (Matthew 5:45) People who live uprightly, treat others fairly, and seek to honour God. They are not perfect, but they are recognisably "just" in daily life. Absolute righteousness (Ecclesiastes 7:20) No human being is morally flawless. Everyone sins. No one is righteous in the ultimate, sinless sense. These two meanings do not conflict. A person can be "just" in the everyday, human sense while still being a sinner in the deeper, theological sense. Why this matters: Together, the verses teach two truths: God is good to all people, regardless of their moral condition. All people need grace, because none are perfectly righteous. This combination is actually central to the biblical story: God's kindness is meant to lead imperfect people toward Him. Summary of the whole topic Matthew 5:45 teaches that God shows kindness to all people, while Ecclesiastes 7:20 states that everyone is flawed and sins. Together, they show that human imperfection is universal, yet God's generosity extends to all, regardless of moral condition.
Daniel Veler
Supporter
Your question is, “How should I interpret Matthew 5:45, where Jesus states that God sends rain to both the righteous and the unrighteous, in light of Ecclesiastes 7:20, which asserts that there is no righteous person on earth who does good without sinning?” Matthew 5:45 implies that bad things happen to both the righteous and the unrighteous. For instance, consider an earthquake that causes hundreds of deaths. While some of these individuals may be righteous, many are also unrighteous. The sole distinction between the two groups in such a scenario lies in the presence of hope in the righteous while its absence in the unrighteous. As for Ecclesiastes 7:20, it highlights God’s predetermined nature of humanity. No one was righteous, not even one. Righteousness only occurs when a person is in Christ. Romans 3:10 states, “As it is written, 'There is none righteous, no, not one: There is none that understandeth, there is none that seeketh after God. They are all gone out of the way, they are together become unprofitable; there is none that doeth good, no, not one.'” The apostles drew from Old Testament scriptures to explain these concepts to the people. In this case, Romans 10 aligns with Ecclesiastes 7:20.
All answers are REVIEWED and MODERATED.
Please ensure your answer MEETS all our guidelines.
A good answer provides new insight and perspective. Here are guidelines to help facilitate a meaningful learning experience for everyone.